Dr Agnes Naa Momo Lartey — Minister for Gender Children and Social Protection in Ghana
Dr Agnes Naa Momo Lartey — Minister for Gender Children and Social Protection in Ghana

What men can do, women can do better: Juxtaposition of Affirmative Action in Ghana

The widely held belief that "what men can do, women can do better" has become a powerful expression of women's capability, challenging traditional assumptions that certain professions and leadership roles are inherently suited for men.

In Ghana's affirmative action context, a fundamental question arises: is gender equality about proving women's superiority or ensuring equal access for both sexes to demonstrate abilities?

This distinction is crucial because affirmative action isn't a competition between men and women but aims to correct historical and structural inequalities that have hindered women's equal opportunities.

The Affirmative Action Act, 2024 (Act 1121) reflects this, setting progressive targets for women's representation in decision-making, while working toward gender parity.

Women can do better

Historically, women have faced social expectations linking leadership, authority and public decision-making with masculinity, forcing women to prove that their gender does not dictate their intellectual capacity, leadership potential or professional competence.

While "women can do better" empowers women by challenging patriarchal norms, it has drawbacks.


Taken literally, it ignores individual variation in talent, skill and capacity because not every woman can outperform every man, just as not every man can outperform every woman.

Moreover, the statement presents an interesting paradox.

On one hand, it is empowering because it challenges patriarchal norms and encourages women to strive beyond traditional limitations.

On the other hand, it reinforces a competitive gender framework that affirmative action seeks to overcome.

If achieving equality requires women to prove they are better than men to gain recognition, then women are still being evaluated against men.

Affirmative action, question of merit

One significant criticism of affirmative action is that it can seem to conflict with the principle of meritocracy.

Critics often ask, shouldn't the most qualified person be awarded a position, regardless of gender?

The answer should indeed be yes, but only if merit competition occurs on a level playing field.

Merit does not exist in isolation.

Factors such as educational opportunities, professional networks, financial resources, mentorship and social expectations all play a role in determining who acquires and demonstrates merit in the first place.

Affirmative action does not aim to appoint an unqualified woman, as this would undermine the institution and the credibility of women who have legitimately earned their positions.


Instead, it seeks to establish mechanisms to ensure that qualified women are not systematically excluded from opportunities. 

Does Affirmative Action discriminate against men?

Another important question is whether affirmative action discriminates against men.

This concern should not be dismissed.

Any policy that gives preference to one group must be carefully designed to avoid creating new forms of unfairness and discrimination.

A woman should not need to be the best candidate in the room simply because she is a woman; she should be assessed based on her qualifications, competence, experience and potential.

 Affirmative action is, therefore, to be understood as a corrective mechanism rather than permanent preferential treatment for women.

Its purpose is to dismantle barriers, broaden participation, and create a system in which women can compete fairly. 

Representation, effective participation

Ghana has made significant strides, yet women's representation in political decision-making remains low, despite women being roughly half the population.

Few women in key decision-making institutions raises concerns about whether the experiences and perspectives of the entire population are adequately represented. 

If women are encouraged to lead but simultaneously criticised for being ambitious, assertive or authoritative, legal reforms alone will have limited impact.

Complementary measures by political parties, society and government are necessary in respect of recruiting and mentoring women candidates, equipping women through training, mentorship, finance, and networks and challenging gender stereotypes.

Conclusion

A truly egalitarian society should not require women to replace men at the top nor should women need to continually outperform men to prove their worth.

A more meaningful reinterpretation of the original statement would be “What men can do, women can do too in a just society” and neither men nor women should have to outdo the other to receive a fair opportunity.

This is the true promise of affirmative action not the supremacy of one gender over the other.

The writer is a strategic public relations, public affairs professional.

E-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.